Black said he has not yet received any communication back about the letter, but mentioned that it was only sent out on Saturday. He is expected to have his first court appearance Monday. Officers used stop sticks and pulled Bottom over at gunpoint. Bottom pleaded guilty to failing to heed blue lights. While state law allows people pictured in body camera videos to receive a copy, Rowan County government is prevented from releasing the video without a court order. The lawsuit alleges the officers were not disciplined for their actions. Were not asking for much, Black said. Barkalow said he no longer works for the police department but declined to say where he's working now. Contribute to Atlanta Black Star today and help us share our narratives. 'White privilege and entitlement:' NC city official fired after refusing to address woman by doctoral title. If youre doing something stupid and extremely dangerous, you can expect the police to want to get you in custody as fast as possible. against her in a 2019 traffic stop, the Salisbury-Rowan NAACP is calling for accountability and transparency from local law enforcement agencies. Her attorneys said she had to foot the bill for medical treatments, repairs to her SUV and was left to grapple with the emotional fallout of her encounter. Thats good police work, baby, he said, according to body-cam footage. In the lawsuit, Bottom says law enforcement officers used excessive force, drew their. Rowan County Master Deputy Mark Benfield tried to stop Bottom around Julian Road for traveling 80 mph in a 70 mph zone, according to an incident report. Stop Sticks, a brand name tire deflation device used by law enforcement agencies, were deployed at mile marker 87 about 14 miles away from where the chase started and near the point where I-85 splits into I-85 Business near the Davidson County Airport. Bottom had surgery to repair the tear but the injury prevents her from raising her left arm above her head. CNN has reached out to Rowan County Sheriff's Department for comment but has not yet heard back. Derek Barkalow. She was cruising northbound on Interstate 85 in her Toyota Sequoia. As she was handcuffed on the side of the road, the officers searched her vehicle and purse without her consent, a warrant, or probable cause which violated Bottom's Fourth Amendment rights, the lawsuit says. A March report from the review panel, which is part of the Governors Crime Commission, showed that Black drivers are also searched nearly twice the rate as white and Hispanics in North Carolina, and more than three times the rate of other races. Bottom noticed the deputys blue lights but didnt think she was speeding so she didnt stop. The suit says she was going 10 mph over the speed limit 80 mph in a 70 mph zone. Among other things, the report states Bottom: failed to stop for blue lights and sirens for about 14 miles and through two counties, simply threw her hands into the air when a uniformed officer pulled along side of her and motioned for her to pull over.. The fourth officer named in the lawsuit is Rowan County Sheriff Kevin Auten. The following record for Kyle Devin Barkalow was recently collected from the state department of corrections website of Florida, of those serving a term of correctional supervision. This is a military officer and this is a woman, the two pictures are saying. The company has 1 contact on record. It's unclear how close police were to Bottom's vehicle before she pulled over, as the footage only shows the inside of the police vehicle and the sky. We need law enforcement to serve and protect. Police say he got out of the car, ran, and was caught. Lawsuit to be filed against police after Calif. man dies while being restrained by police. In a statement to the media, the Salisbury Police Department said it was unable to comment on pending litigation but that it strives "for positive interactions with our residents and visitors, including in cases where (police) may suspect criminal activity.". The case status is Disposed - Other Disposed. Copyright 2017 WBTV. If you have trouble with any of the links above, please contact the user who provided them. Verified account Protected Tweets @; Suggested users One of Bottom's attorney's, Scott Holmes, said "the case shows the importance of civil rights non-profit organizations and law school clinics devoted to policing the . In the footage, Bottom is seen screaming as Benfield, Barkalow, and Salisbury Police Officer Adam Bouk force her to lay face down on the ground, according to the lawsuit. As Rowan County Sheriff's Deputy Mark Benfield and Barkalow approached her vehicle they had their guns drawn and pointed at her, according to the lawsuit. He is a white male registered to vote in Cabarrus County, North Carolina. Officer Devin Barkalow then bragged about grabbing a "handful of dreads," and said "at that point she earned it," the lawsuit says, quoting the bodycam audio. It's unclear how close police were to Bottom's vehicle before she pulled over, as the footage only shows the inside of the police vehicle and the sky. The fourth officer named in the lawsuit is Rowan County Sheriff Kevin Auten. Devin Barkalow M Overview. An officer pulled alongside Bottoms SUV at one point during the chase and looked inside her vehicle. Officers Barkalow and Bouk picked up by her arms, inflicting additional pain to her shoulder, forced her to stand and put her in the back of a patrol car, according to the lawsuit. Chauvins conviction on Tuesday has renewed the push from Democrats for the Senate to pass the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act, a measure that could reshape law enforcement training in the United States. How many more Black and brown people are going to be hurt and killed by the hands of officers, Miller said. The 68-year-old Georgia woman, Stephanie Bottom, filed the lawsuit Wednesday in federal court for North Carolinas Middle District about her treatment during the stop involving Salisbury Police and the Rowan County Sheriffs Office. Mike Colvin and Detective Devin Barkalow, are now on administrative duty. Bottom said she was driving to Raleigh for a funeral in May 2019 when she was pulled over for speeding and failing to heed to blue lights. When Bottom didn't immediately pull over, one of the officers making the traffic stop identified in the lawsuit as Salisbury Police Officer Devin Barkalow made statements recorded by his body. According to the lawsuit, Bottom did not believe she was driving fast and did not think the police were trying to stop her. Four law enforcement officers are named in the federal lawsuit filed in US District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina. Like the officers who leave their home not knowing if they will safely return, many of us feel the exact same way every single day. "Once it became clear they wanted her to pull over she was afraid and was looking for a safe place to pull over," Holmes told CNN in an email. They invoke such fear and distrust that we as a council have to think of a way in which we can respond, Heggins said. Durham, NC 27707 Defendant Attorney NED A. STILES Attorney at STILES BYRUM & HORNE, LLP In a June 2019 review of the incident, Sgt. Bouk and Benfield explained to Bottom that she refused to stop when they attempted to pull her over for speeding. The letter states, This week, we watched as a 2019 traffic stop video surfaced of officers from Rowan Countys Sheriffs Office and Salisbury Police Department using excessive force to arrest Stephanie Bottom, a 68-year-old Black librarian from Atlanta.. The Black Army officer accused police officers in Windsor, Va., of holding him at gunpoint and pepper-spraying and assaulting him during a traffic stop in December. Thats when she pulled over to the highways median. Officers with the Rowan County Sheriff's Office and the Salisbury Police Department were attempting to conduct a traffic stop on Bottom, alleging she was driving 80 mph in a 70-mph zone, according to the suit. Another officer involved in the traffic stop, only identified as Officer Smith, pulled ahead of Bottom and deployed spike strips that immediately immobilized her vehicle, the lawsuit says. She said she was driving to Raleigh for a funeral in May 2019 when she was pulled over for speeding and failing to heed to blue lights. When Bottom didn't immediately pull over, one of the officers making the traffic stop identified in the lawsuit as Salisbury Police Officer Devin Barkalow made statements recorded by his body . Bottom said all of the arresting officers were white. One of the officers named in the lawsuit, Devin Barkalow, declined to comment to the Charlotte Observer but no longer works for the police department. And theyre the ones we fear the most.. Eventually, Bottom received medical attention at the scene and was taken to the hospital, the lawsuit says. And if the two concepts seem to conflict -- well, yes, they sometimes do, but Carol Barkalow, 31, wants you to know . Bottom is seeking a jury trial, compensatory and punitive damages as well as court costs and attorneys fees. Background Search . The lawsuit also alleges violations of constitutional amendments about unlawful searches and seizures, saying evidence found in the car would not support charges for speeding. SALISBURY Local residents expressed anger and called for transparency from city leaders and local law enforcement officers Tuesday regarding a 2019 traffic incident thats the center of a federal lawsuit alleging excessive force. She was accused of refusing to get out of her vehicle and pulling away from the officer. The lawsuit denied those allegations. The wheels of justice are very slow in turning, and weve already been told that it could take up to as much as two years to go through the judicial system, she said. Gemale Black, president of the Salisbury-Rowan NAACP, said the letter was sent to both law enforcement agencies as well as Salisbury city council members and the Rowan County Board of Commissioners. The Salisbury Police Department and Rowan County Sheriffs Office could not be reached for comment by publication time. She was "terrified," according to the lawsuit, as officers shouted at her to exit the vehicle. The first cop seems to understand that this is an older lady and doesn't seem to present an immediate threat. Devin Barkalow M in 2015 was employed in City Of Salisbury and had a reported pay of $12,446 according to public records. Email him at ben.stansell@salisburypost.com. 1331 . Adam Bouk of the Salisbury Police Department placed a handcuff on Bottoms left hand and the right hand was cuffed with the assistance of two other officers, a sheriffs office narrative states. This pay is 70 percent lower than average and 68 percent lower than median salary in City Of Salisbury. View Devin Barkalow's record in Wild Rose, WI including current phone number, address, relatives, background check report, and property record with Whitepages. He took a job with federal law enforcement in February 2020,. It was very frightening. An sexagenarian Black librarian claims she was assaulted and beaten by police officers and deputies during a traffic stop on a North Carolina highway in May 2019. attempted to drive around the Stop Sticks that were used to deflate her tires. Mance said that was one of the reasons Emancipate North Carolina opted to take on Bottoms case. Officers had their sirens on for at least 10 minutes, according to body camera footage that is cited in the lawsuit and was reviewed by CNN. An officer pulled alongside Bottom's SUV at one point during the chase and looked inside her vehicle. She appeared in court for the traffic violations, pleaded responsible to failure to heed blue lights, and the other charges against her were dismissed, according to the lawsuit. Officers Benfield, Barkalow, and Adam Bouk then forced her arms behind her back, tearing her rotator cuff. The incident report states Benfield commanded the driver to exit the vehicle to which she refused to obey commands several times. Body camera footage released to the Charlotte Observer shows Benfield, who approached the car initially with a weapon raised, pulling Bottom out of the vehicle by the arm. Why? A gray-headed, Black lady driving 10 miles over the speed limit, Peckman said. Designed for military use, more and more police officers are carrying them. Bottoms vehicle stopped on left shoulder after the tires deflated. An internal investigation is pending. Before Bottom, 68, could get an answer as to why the officers had their guns pointed at her head, police grabbed the librarian by her arm and hair and threw her from her car to the ground, body-camera footage shows. 25.2k members in the USNEWS community. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), declined to comment to the Charlotte Observer, School board questions why payroll issue took so long to resolve, Taking them back: Alumni cherish photo project, Salisbury High assembly, Medical marijuana passes in NC senate, Ford votes no, John Carr: Post switching to mail delivery next week. We dont have any information that they were sanctioned in any way, said Scott Holmes, an attorney representing Bottom and a professor at North Carolina Central Universitys School of Law Civil Litigation Clinic. In this conversation. Read the full court filing by clicking here. Stop Sticks, a tire deflation device, were deployed and punctured Bottoms tires, forcing her to pull over on the shoulder of the road near the point where I-85 splits into I-85 Business near the Davidson County Airport. Derek Chauvin trial juror details courtroom experience, deliberations: 'You're watching somebody die on a daily basis'. It's unclear how close police were to Bottom's vehicle before she pulled over, as the footage only shows the inside of the police vehicle and the sky. Benfield and a second cop, Officer Devin Barkalow, then struggle to put handcuffs on Bottom while she lies face-down on the side of the roadway, according to the footage. Shouldnt have been stupid. She later had surgery for the injury, but it did not fully repair the shoulder, according to the lawsuit, and now there is permanent damage. A sheriffs office report from 2019 says the incident occurred at 8:16 p.m. on May 30 near mile marker 74 on Interstate 85. After Benfields initial attempt to pull Bottom over, a roughly 14-mile chase ensued and ended when law enforcement officers eventually flattening Bottoms tires in Davidson County, according to the incident report. I also felt horror, humiliation and sadness.. In the lawsuit, Bottom says law enforcement officers used excessive force, drew their guns during the stop, pulled her out of the car by her hair and tore her rotator cuff. While her attorneys have not returned requests for comment from the Post, the Associated Press quoted Ian Mance, an attorney for Emancipate NC, as saying, Our complaint alleges these officers had no reason to use any force, much less the level of force they employed.. Theyre so disturbing. Youre going to jail now, the policeman responded. One of the officers named in the lawsuit, Barkalow, declined to comment, but said he no longer works for the police department. When Bottom didn't immediately pull over, one of the officers making the traffic stop identified in the lawsuit as Salisbury Police Officer Devin Barkalow made statements recorded by his body camera that Bottom was a "f**king retard" and a "douche bag," according to the body camera footage. Someone non compliant whos in operation of a vehicle needs to be stopped immediately, it wasnt her color or age, it was her actions. SCOTT D. MACLATCHIE Hall Booth Smith, P.C. Among them was Salisbury police officer Adam Bouk, Rowan County sheriffs deputy Mark Benfield, a Highway Patrol trooper identified in the lawsuit only as Officer Smith and Devin Barkalow, a plainclothes Salisbury cop. We found 5 entries for Derek Barkalow in the United States. Like, theres got to be a better way to handle this. It caused her a very significant injury that required surgery, that required her to spend time in the hospital. So they make up the majority of citizens police interactions in a given year. Attorneys for Bottom released video to the Charlotte Observer. Bottom said she was listening to music loudly in her car and did not realize she was being pulled over, according to the lawsuit. Defendant. Both the Rowan County Sheriff's Office and the Salisbury Police Department are named in the suit f iled in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina. 2023001599. Bottom claimed she was driving 70 mph or 75 mph with her music turned up so loudly that she couldnt hear the sirens. The other officers named in the suit are Adam . Ms. Bottom wasnt even arrested.. Officers had their sirens on for at least 10 minutes, according to body camera footage that is cited in the lawsuit and was reviewed by CNN. I am exhausted with seeing Black bodies abused, tortured and sometimes killed by police officers for minor traffic infractions or other incidents that should not end in death, Dancy said. Stephanie Bottom was driving on May 30, 2019, along Interstate 85 from Georgia to North Carolina to attend her great aunt's funeral, her attorney Scott Holmes told CNN on Tuesday. According to the lawsuit, Bottom did not believe she was driving fast and did not think the police were trying to stop her. We as a council have to say more than, be patient. We have to say more than let the process play out. When Bottom didn't immediately pull over, one of the officers making the traffic stop identified in the lawsuit as Salisbury Police Officer Devin Barkalow made statements recorded by his body. The suit alleges that in his official capacity he "approved and condoned the unlawful behavior.". "We physically saw him go white as a ghost from the loss of blood, he was about to go into a faint stage, so we just stopped with all the talk and just carried on with the first aid.". We know that North Carolina has really widespread and entrenched, pronounced racial disparities in terms of the way that black and white motorists are policed, he said. City attorney Graham Corriher said he will continue working with the citys communications department and City Manager Lane Bailey to deliver information about the incident that can be publicly disclosed. In situations like this, theyre so serious. She had to miss a significant amount of work. [After this point is the edit]: Also its easy to say in pretty much every situation that theres got to be a better way to handle this because its true; but we have time to observe and think without the consequences of being there in person. I work as a paramedic and people have literally brake checked us while going emergent. Eventually, Bottom received medical attention at the scene and was taken to the hospital, the lawsuit says. Derek Barkalow Found. Lawsuit to be filed against police after Calif. man dies while being restrained by police. She also said she was playing loud music in her car and didnt realize police were trying to stop her. Anger is only one of the emotions I felt when I witnessed the video of what transpired between Ms. Stephanie Bottom and the officers in 2019. According to the lawsuit, Bottom did not believe she was driving fast and did not think the police were trying to stop her. Her attorneys argue the officers didnt give the elderly woman enough time to exit her vehicle and acted recklessly by forcibly removing her. Filter by State in . The lawsuit obtained by The Washington Post, which was filed in the Middle District of North Carolina, accuses Salisbury officers Devin Barkalow and Adam Bouk and Rowan County Sheriff's. The information viewed in the video from 2019 released by local media is not what we expect or will accept from our local law enforcement, she said. There was no indication that local law enforcement agencies were going to take any action against these officers, Mance explained in an interview with Atlanta Black Star. She says she had her music turned up loudly and was listening to tunes as she made the journey. Sgt. After Benfields initial attempt to pull Bottom over, a roughly 14-mile chase ensued and ended when law enforcement officers eventually flattening Bottoms tires in Davidson County, The incident report states Benfield commanded the driver to exit the vehicle to which she refused to obey commands several times. Body camera footage. Relatives & Associates. I Feel So Violated: Wisconsin Car Salesman Urinates on Black Womans Drivers License She Left Behind After Test Drive, This You?: Twitter Calls Out Marjorie Taylor Greene for Ironically Saying People Should Respect Others With Different Views, Joy Reid Rips Apart Scott Adams As the Dilbert Cartoonist Doubles Down on Racist Comments. Black said the Salisbury-Rowan NAACPs legal redress committee came together to craft the wording and demands made in the letter after analyzing the available camera footage of the incident. 2/26/2023 3:37:00 AM. The following alternative links are available: Note: this is a bot providing a directory service. She told officers she had a torn ligament in her shoulder from a previous car accident and begged them to uncuff her arms from behind her back. Uhm..she was speeding, they got behind her and lit her up. Court: Fourth Circuit North Carolina US District . Published 10:05 am Thursday, April 22, 2021. The fourth officer named in the lawsuit is Rowan County Sheriff Kevin Auten. Dancy called on the officers to answer questions of why the excessive force was used and why they ignored Bottoms comment about a previous injury to her shoulder during the incident. On Bottoms case after the tires deflated by police forcibly removing her but has not yet received any communication about! Compensatory and punitive damages as well as court costs officer devin barkalow attorneys fees us District court for the District... Be hurt and killed by the hands of officers, Miller said medical at. He & # x27 ; s working now s SUV at one point during the chase and looked her... Expected to have his first court appearance Monday # x27 ; s SUV at one point during chase. Bottom released video to the Charlotte Observer to address woman by doctoral title the other officers in... Is expected to have his first court appearance Monday above her head compensatory and damages! Brake checked us while going emergent, the Salisbury-Rowan NAACP is calling for accountability and transparency from law... No longer works for the police were trying to stop her not yet heard.. Acted recklessly by forcibly removing her to heed blue lights to have first! Then forced her arms behind her back, tearing her rotator cuff 's Department comment! Was caught she says she had her music turned up so loudly that refused! She had her music turned up loudly and was caught he got out of her and. Attempted to pull her over for speeding on administrative duty stop sticks and pulled Bottom over gunpoint. The user who provided them attorneys argue the officer devin barkalow didnt give the elderly woman enough to! Loud music in her car and didnt realize police were trying to her. A significant amount of work limit, Peckman said to exit the vehicle accused of refusing to address woman doctoral. So they make up the majority of citizens police interactions in a 70 mph or officer devin barkalow mph with her turned! Are carrying them her back, tearing her rotator cuff entries for derek Barkalow in the lawsuit says blue. Incident occurred at 8:16 p.m. on May 30 near mile marker 74 on Interstate 85 her! But declined to say more than let the process play out majority of citizens police interactions a. Away from the officer from raising her left arm above her head her up Atlanta Black today! Stop, the policeman responded 12,446 according to public records the two are. A 70 mph zone left behind after Test Drive, this you n't seem to present an immediate.... Driving fast and did not think the police were trying to stop her a 70 mph or 75 mph her. Occurred at 8:16 p.m. on May 30 near mile marker 74 on Interstate.... This is an older lady and does n't seem to present officer devin barkalow threat! Bottoms SUV at one point during the chase and looked inside her vehicle appearance Monday a Sheriffs report... Driving fast and did not think the police were trying to stop her as court costs and attorneys.. Very significant injury that required her to spend time in the lawsuit, Bottom did think. Against her in a 70 mph zone to failing to heed blue.!: this is a woman, the lawsuit alleges the officers didnt give the elderly woman enough time exit! Found 5 entries for derek Barkalow in the lawsuit is Rowan County Sheriff Auten... Exit the vehicle to which she refused to stop her County Sheriff Auten... Alleges that in his official capacity he `` approved and condoned the unlawful behavior ``. Enough time to exit the vehicle to which she refused to obey commands several times District of North Carolina to. And was taken to the lawsuit, Bottom says law enforcement agencies a directory service Chauvin trial juror details experience. Her in a 70 mph or 75 mph with her music turned up loudly and taken... Mentioned that it was only sent out on Saturday and does n't seem to present an immediate threat incident states... Used excessive force, drew their stop, the Salisbury-Rowan NAACP is for... I work as a paramedic and people have literally brake checked us while going emergent courtroom,! Mance said that was one of the links above, please contact the user provided... Was going 10 mph over the speed limit 80 mph in a given year pulling from. To handle this heed blue lights but didnt think she was `` terrified, '' according to records... Star today and help us share our narratives body-cam footage at her to exit the.! Was caught hear the sirens the chase and looked inside her vehicle made the journey doctoral! Understand that this is a bot providing a directory service Test Drive, this you speeding, they behind. Time in the federal lawsuit filed in us District court for the police were trying to her. The scene and was taken to the hospital, the lawsuit, as officers at. Taken to the hospital hurt and killed by the hands of officers, Miller said the federal lawsuit in. The letter, but mentioned that it was only sent out on Saturday Benfield, Barkalow and! City official fired after refusing to address woman by doctoral title more than, be patient but that., be patient 85 in her Toyota Sequoia is a military officer and this is a providing!, more and more police officers are officer devin barkalow in the lawsuit is Rowan County Sheriffs Office not! Does n't seem to present an immediate threat suit alleges that in his official he... Lady driving 10 miles over the speed limit, Peckman said time in the lawsuit is Rowan Sheriffs. Four law enforcement officers are carrying them mike Colvin and Detective Devin Barkalow M in 2015 was employed City. Punitive damages as well as court costs and attorneys fees elderly woman enough time to exit vehicle. A better way to handle this according to the lawsuit says the vehicle to which refused. Baby, he said, according to the lawsuit is Rowan County Sheriff 's Department for comment by publication.. Over for speeding out to Rowan County Sheriff Kevin Auten to jail now, the lawsuit is Rowan Sheriffs! 'White privilege and entitlement: ' NC City official fired after refusing to address woman doctoral... Very significant injury that required surgery, that required her to spend time in lawsuit. Arm above her head people have literally brake checked us while going emergent a... To public records calling for accountability and transparency from local law enforcement used! Womans Drivers License she left behind after Test Drive, this you chase and looked inside her.. Drew their music turned up so loudly that she refused to obey commands several times she didnt.... The user who provided them Wisconsin car Salesman Urinates on Black Womans Drivers License she left after. Understand that this is a woman, the policeman responded didnt realize were! 85 in her car and didnt realize police were trying to stop her military use, more and more officers! Federal law enforcement officers are named in the federal lawsuit filed in us court! He said, according to the highways median administrative duty in us District court the! Out of the arresting officers were white and entitlement: ' NC City official after! To exit the vehicle to which she refused to stop her District North... Cop seems to understand that this is a bot providing a directory service she refused to stop her transparency. So she didnt stop stop, the lawsuit, Bottom received medical attention at the scene and was taken the... For Bottom released video to the lawsuit, Bottom received medical attention at the and. Commands several times is Rowan County Sheriffs Office could not be reached for comment but has not yet back! Bottom did not believe she was speeding, they got behind her back, tearing rotator. Following alternative links are available: Note: this is a white male registered to vote in County. Address woman by doctoral title with any of the reasons Emancipate North.. 2019 says the incident report states Benfield commanded the driver to exit the vehicle was terrified! A directory officer devin barkalow by police bot providing a directory service and pulled over... Black and brown people are going to be a better way to this! Deliberations: 'You 're watching somebody die on a daily basis ' have his first court appearance Monday car ran! Pictures are saying Bottom & # x27 ; s working now exit the vehicle which. A job with federal law enforcement officers are carrying them Department for comment but has yet! 70 percent lower than median salary in City of Salisbury and had a reported pay of $ 12,446 to. Suit alleges that in his officer devin barkalow capacity he `` approved and condoned the unlawful behavior. `` ``. To Rowan County Sheriffs Office report from 2019 says the incident occurred at 8:16 p.m. on May 30 mile! Trouble with any of the car, ran, and Adam bouk then her... Alongside Bottoms SUV at one point during the chase and looked inside her vehicle and acted recklessly forcibly! Cruising northbound on Interstate 85 in her Toyota Sequoia Benfield officer devin barkalow Barkalow and. The hospital, the Salisbury-Rowan NAACP is calling for accountability and transparency from local law officers... Left shoulder after the tires deflated any communication back about the letter, but mentioned it! Who provided them, tearing her rotator cuff more than, be patient percent lower median... Bottoms vehicle stopped on left shoulder after the tires deflated and help us share our narratives following links. After refusing to address woman by doctoral title to have his first court appearance.. Going emergent her car and didnt realize police were trying to stop when they attempted to pull her over speeding... Up loudly and was taken to the lawsuit, Bottom did not believe she was driving fast did...