Ten of those punctures were found on her neck. My prayers will continue to be with your family during this time of mourning and the days and months ahead. In homicides, McDonald explained, shallow stab wounds are uncommon. This is critical, attorney Joe Podraza tells "48 Hours." My thoughts and prayers are with you in your time of need. She will surely be missed by all. At approximately 6:40 p.m. on January 26, 2011, Ellen was pronounced dead as a result of twenty stab wounds, including ten to the back of her head and neck. I still remember the first time Ellen called me to tell me we were going to be each other's first roommates at Penn State we were both SO excited. She was always looking out for her students & I visit the memorial garden we have at jpa all the time . Legal battle over Ellen Greenberg's death continues. But after a half an hour or so at the gym, Sam returned to the couple's apartment to find the swing bolt latched. Ellen had been on antianxiety medication. She will be missed by so many. No matter how much they scratch around, its still going to stink.. In a report co-authored with fellow scientist Elaine Pagliaro in 2018, both concluded: "The number and types of wounds and bloodstain patterns observed are consistent with a homicide scene.". Words cannot express how much I miss her. Husband of woman murdered with an ax convicted 40 years after her death, The Brighton ax murder: A timeline of the 40-year-old cold case, How a tragic boating crash is connected to the family of Alex Murdaugh, Chilling details revealed in JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan deaths, Moms chatting at a water park help crack a cold case murder, family attorney Joe Podraza tells CBS Philly. [6] A new technology called photogrammetry, unavailable at the time of Ellen's death, created a 3D anatomical recreation of Ellen's wounds, demonstrating that not all 20 wounds could have been self-inflicted. This is all the surveillance footage the Philadelphia Police Department would release to the Greenberg family. This baffled the Greenbergs, particularly since their daughter was wedding planning. He accompanies Ellen to the morgue. Of course, this all happened after the crime scene was professionally cleaned. Resend Activation Email, Please check the I'm not a robot checkbox, If you want to be a Photo Volunteer you must enter a ZIP Code or select your location on the map. May God bless you and your family in this time of sorrow. PHILADELPHIA (CBS) -- The legal battle over the controversial death of Ellen Greenberg has spilled into appeals court. My mom has often spoken so highly of Ellen and I am so sorry to hear of your loss. If youre in charge of handling the affairs for a recently deceased loved one, this guide offers a helpful checklist. Year should not be greater than current year. Family members linked to this person will appear here. She lived with her partner Samuel 'Sam' Goldberg in an apartment in Manayunk, Philadelphia. People are curious To know what caused his death. February 17, 2022 / 7:31 PM There's nothing I can say that will comfort anyone that knew of Ellen's beautiful spirit. Try again. Arie Luyendyk Jr. Parents, Siblings And Family. There was no sign of any intruder, forced entry, or evidence of a struggle, according to an investigation report by the City of Philadelphia, Office of the Medical Examiner. I was one of the first graders to first find out threw the news . She will be greatly missed. [9] However, despite there being no suicide note, the crime scene was treated as a suicide. Giving to charity is a meaningful way to honor someone who has died. Dr. Wayne K. Ross, another expert the family consulted in 2017, mentions the stab wound that penetrated the brain. Ellen will always be an inspiration to many as I feel cheated in that I never had the pleasure of meeting this beautiful person. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Ellen is a kindred spirit. The main facts in the case how Ellen was found and how many wounds she had are not in dispute. I am at a loss for words. Ellen Rae Greenberg, 27, of Philadelphia and formerly of Harrisburg, passed away in her home on Wednesday, January 26, 2011. Her search history reportedly included the terms suicide methods," "quick suicide," and "painless suicide., It remainsunclear why this forensics report wasnt included in the medical examiners 2011 investigation, which stated there wasnt anything indicative of suicide on the computers or in the rest of the apartment., Brennan, the former Pennsylvania detective, called the attorney generals findings totally ridiculous., Theres not enough litter in the box, he said. Rest in peace. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. Ellen will always be remembered. Once inside he found Ellen supine with her head and some of her upper body resting against the lower kitchen cabinets with a 10-inch serrated steak knife sticking out of her chest. You are only allowed to leave one flower per day for any given memorial. "She did not kill herself," Sandee Greenberg, Ellen's mother, said. We were all blessed to have known her. Please know all our thoughts are with you. Miss greenberg was a very large inspiration to my son Montez. Ellen was born on June 23rd of 1983. in New York City. My family and I are very saddened for your loss. Teachers guide the stars. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. Her psychiatrist told police there were never any indications of physical or verbal abuse between the couple. Postles claimed that he discovered the lump a few, Read More Is Don Postles Hospitalized? She was born on June 23, 1983 in New York, NY to Joshua & Sandra. Tim Cooney told the Inquirer. "You can tell that it's very improbable that Ellen could inflict the wounds from behind. The process, called photogrammetry, allowed the legal team to recreate Ellen's anatomical and physiological attributes. An injury like that, he writes, would lead Ellen to have "severe pain, cranial nerve disfunction and traumatic brain signs" as well as "numbness, tingling [and] irregular heartbeat. March 11, 2020 / 2:37 PM Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. memorial page for Ellen Rae Greenberg (23 Jun 1983-26 Jan 2011), Find a Grave Memorial ID 64780765, citing Chisuk Emuna Cemetery, . She was anxious but she was still happy, her father, Joshua Greenberg, added. Robin (A Phila. For eight years,Joshua and Sandee Greenberghave tirelessly investigated the death oftheir 27-year-old daughter, Ellen, who was found stabbed to death in her apartment. But investigators told reporters the next day they were "leaning" towards suicide, according to the Inquirer. She made learning fun for her students and was a ray of sunshine where ever she was. The Greenbergs are now hoping their case goes to trial. Even something as small as teaching me and Matthew how to blow bubble gum sticks with me as one of my fondest memories. What Happened To Him- Illness And Health UpdateContinue, Views are curious about Emmett Till Killer after announcing a new play, Trial in the Delta: The Murder of Emmett Till, revolving around his murder mystery. In another shooting, two teenagers were shot, and one died later at the hospital while being treated. At the time of her death, Ellen was 27-years-old and she was a first grade teacher at Juniata Park Academy in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. . ). 0 cemeteries found in Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania, USA. -sarah(student), We are so terribly sorry to hear about Ellen and this terrible tragedy. It's been a very long time, and I've grown so much, but I'll never forget you. I am so very saddened by the loss of Ellen. Ellen's family got some bad news at the end of February when the Pennsylvania attorney general's office reviewed the case again and still supports suicide as her cause of death. [2], On March 15, 2019, The Philadelphia Inquirer released a front-page investigative report reviewing the suspicious circumstances surrounding the death of Ellen Greenberg. Greenberg hadnt sustained any injuries consistent with self-defense in a knife attack. Elementary school teacher Ellen Greenbergsent her first grade students home early on Jan. 26, 2011a nasty blizzard was on the verge of slamming the northeast. He said its possible Ellen was taken by complete surprise when she was stabbed. They are James Schwartzman, Sam Goldberg's uncle who is a prominent attorney in Philadelphia; Kamian Schwartzman, Sam Goldberg's cousin and close friend who is also James Schwartzman's son; Richard Goldberg, Sam Goldberg's father; and Mindy Goldberg, Sam Goldberg's mother. Love you sister. I am very saddened to hear the loss of my peer, Ellen. This flower has been reported and will not be visible while under review. I send my prayers and the prayers of all her fellow classmates at Chestnut Hill to her family. Arrangements are being handled by the Hetrick-Bitner Funeral Home. He also questioned why she would have stopped to get gas on her way home if she was planning to commit suicide just a short time later. She was a wonderful and beautiful person. She was a beautiful person and will remain in my memory as such. Use the links under See more to quickly search for other people with the same last name in the same cemetery, city, county, etc. January 26th, 2021 is the 10th anniversary of Ellen Rae Greenberg's unfortunate death. She was always genuinely interested in what I had to say, and I would listen with wide eyes to all of the experiences she told me about. Linda Roth. This account already exists, but the email address still needs to be confirmed. It is no surprise that the Greenbergs were greatly dissatisfied with the AG's handling of their daughter's matter," their attorney Joseph Podraza, Jr.,said in a statement to the news outlet. They talked about taxes and the snow falling there in Pennsylvania. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Upon hearing the tragic news, we immediately envisioned Ellen running, no bouncing, across the tennis courts as a competitive STHS tennis player. Ellen A Greenberg <p>Ellen A. Greenberg age 90 of Nowthen, passed into the arms of her Lord and Savior on March 20, 2022.</p> <p>Ellen was born on October 21, 1931 to Herman and Alvina Holmquist on a farm in Clarissa, MN.</p> <p>She attended country grade-school and later graduated from Clarissa High School in 1949. They tell her that the crime scene has been releases, so he may enter. Her giving goes on and on as does all who love her. My prayers are with you, I will always remember her beautiful smile and the loving way she spoke of her students. Please enter valid email address to continue. 2020 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. She was a great and loving teacher to her students. We were deeply saddened to hear of your tragic loss. Ellen Greenberg's story was featured in the Dr. Oz Show,[15] People Magazine,[16] 48 Hours,[9] Inside Edition,[17] The Philadelphia Inquirer, CBS Philadelphia,[18] Good Day Philadelphia (FOX29 Philly),[19] ABC Harrisburg, CBS Harrisburg, Penn Live, NBC's Oxygen network, the Daily Mail (UK), Law.com, and FreakTV (Portuguese). They will cooperate and provide whatever assurance that can to the Chester County DA if and when requested. Suicidal stab wounds can rarely be multiple, Wecht wrote in the 2012 report. / CBS News. Ellen was a teacher with the Juniata Academy and a member of Beth El Temple of Harrisburg. 2023 CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Oops, we were unable to send the email. The whole thing, it just didnt make sense. Jim Villarreal/Mr V. I knew Ellen from the STHS softball team and remember looking up to her, one of my older and wiser teammates. Continuing with this request will add an alert to the cemetery page and any new volunteers will have the opportunity to fulfill your request. Investigators initially ruled Ellen Greenberg's death a suicide after concluding there were no signs of forced entry but the Chester County District Attorney's Office has recently announced it. cemeteries found within miles of your location will be saved to your photo volunteer list. Wecht said he was delighted the case would be re-examined by the Chester County District Attorneys Office. They are hopeful for justice for Ellen.". She lived with her partner Samuel 'Sam' Goldberg in an apartment in Manayunk, Philadelphia. There is 1 volunteer for this cemetery. At some point his uncle, James C. Schwartzman, is present. We encourage you to research and examine . A deposition of a city-hired medical expert was also referenced in Tuesday's case. memorial page for Ellen Rae Greenberg (23 Jun 1983-26 Jan 2011), . Who Are Arie Luyendyk And Mieke Luyendyk? It also stated that she was "insecure [and] not sure of herself.". Its possible, but thats one of the things that struck me as not being consistent with a homicide.. I'm very saddness by what has happened. May God give comfort and strength to your Greenberg/Schwab families during this very difficult time. The appellate court has not said when they would decide if this case should move to a trial. Please take some time, even if it's just a few minutes every couple of days, and watch these videos. They dont get the opportunity to defend themselves.. Justice for Ellen/Facebook. After eight years of twists and turns in their heart-wrenching saga to to unearth the truth behind their daughters demise, the Greenbergs feel authorities have failed them once again. My deepest sympathies go out to you. I remember your dear Ellen as a sixth grader: intelligent, vivacious, caring, just full of life, and I must add, a gal with beautiful penmanship. Please enter valid email address to continue. Ellen is the daughter of Joshua Greenberg and Sandra Greenberg, who both work in the dental field. It's possible that when they arrived, they were caught on camera. Ellen was dead of multiple stab wounds at approximately 6:40 pm that evening. In the weeks before her death, Ellen had been visiting psychiatrist Ellen Berman for what was described in the investigative report as severe anxiety. She mentioned in her therapy sessions that she was having difficulty with work and felt overwhelmed. But she reported nothing but good things about her fianc. I pray that your family is strengthened and filled with the peace of God even during this time of mourning. The move has come as welcome news to Ellens parents, who have long insisted their daughter did not take her own life. GOD be with you all. Goldberg then forced open the door and found Ellen slumped against a cabinet. Its been more than a decade since a Pennsylvania teacher was found dead in her kitchen with more than 20 stabs wounds and a knife still plunged into her chest. Dear Greenberg Family,I am so sorry for your loss.You will be in my prayers. : Conflicting Findings Arise in Stabbing Death of Pa. They said there were no signs of intrusion, and the victim had no defensive wounds. [10] However, the next day, the Philadelphia Police Department backtracked and stated that, "the death of Ellen Greenberg has not been ruled a homicideHomicide investigators are considering the manner of death as suspicious at this time. Ellen was a fantastic teacher and a great person. But Tom Brennan, a retired state trooper of 24 years and a former detective, who also represents the Greenbergs, said that theory isnt airtightand doesnt necessarily mean Ellens injuries were self-inflicted. based on information from your browser. I hope that his sincerity will help your hearts to heal. Gregory McDonald, a Montgomery County coroner and the dean of the School of Health Science at the Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine, was one of them. Shortly after, an autopsy reversed Greenbergs cause of death tohomicide. Ellens mom Sandee Greenberg told police that her daughter had been struggling with something before her death but was not suicidal. In order to protect her employer, Ms. Ware makes a video recording of the state of the apartment prior to having the apartment cleaned. The sponsor of a memorial may add an additional. She chickened out [of getting her ears pierced]she didn't like pain, her own pain, said Joshua. No animated GIFs, photos with additional graphics (borders, embellishments. Sim Wong Hoo is the CEO and co-founder of Creative Technology, a Singaporean multinational technology Company known for its computer software, audio and video products, and digital entertainment products. Sim Wong Hoo, the CEO of Creative Technology, has recently passed away. "However, I have no recollection of such a case.". May your memories bring you comfort. First published on March 11, 2020 / 2:37 PM. Dear Sammy, You will be in our thoughts and prayers.Love Paul& Linda Maguire. AS we got to know each other better, I saw that she was a great fit for a job with the football team which I was already doing; she was a natural fit. For the past eight years, the first grade teachers parents have been waging a painstaking, and so far fruitless, crusade to uncover what exactly happened to their only child. She was born on June 23, 1983 in New York, NY to Joshua & Sandra (Rubin) Greenberg. The AGs office pointed to new computer forensic evidencenot referenced in the medical examiners 2011 findings. She had been stabbed more than 20 times with wounds to the back of her skull, neck and chest. Ilagosa Wa Ilagosa is a Kenyan Musician famed for his hit songs Ndakuyasta, Kama Sio Wewe and Unaniwazia Mema. Ms. Greenberg was a great teacher to my child. It was a typical conversation. Please check your email and click on the link to activate your account. Oops, something didn't work. First published on February 17, 2022 / 7:31 PM. Try again later. Joshua describes Ellen as a girly girl who was very athletic. Source: Security Footage, Source: Autopsy Report, Video interview with Tom Brennan. Working with Ellen was a pleasure and it is so sad to hear that we have lost such a beutiful person. Ellen Rae Greenberg had everything going for her when she was found dead in the apartment she shares with her fianc. It was a pleasure and honor to have known Ellen. In November 2022, an appeals court heard arguments. We didnt like what was happening, Joshua explained. Your account has been locked for 30 minutes due to too many failed sign in attempts. Sign the Justice for Ellen petition. New York, New York County (Manhattan), New York, USA, Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, USA. I am very sorry i was unable to attend the funeral. Surviving in addition to her parents are her maternal grandmother Linda (Rubin) Schwab of Harrisburg and her fianc Samuel Hankin Goldberg of Gladwyne, PA. Funeral services will be held at 1 pm on Friday, January 28, 2011 in the Beth El Temple Sanctuary, 2637 North Front Street, Harrisburg, PA, with Rabbi Eric Cytryn officiating. Dramatizing the case in collaboration with theatre at the DuSable Black History Museum and, Read More Who Are Emmett Till Killer Roy Bryant And J.W. Published by The Philadelphia Inquirer on Jan. 28, 2011. Greenberg's parents, however, remain convinced that . To send condolences to the Greenberg family please go to www.hetrickbitner.com. The snow ended up getting worse, and the school was dismissed early. When requested to Ellens parents, who have long insisted their daughter did take! The Greenberg family said there were no signs of intrusion, and am... Of Harrisburg for any given memorial Sam & # x27 ; Sam & # x27 ; s unfortunate death your. 2022 / 7:31 PM there 's nothing I can say that will comfort anyone that knew Ellen. Complete surprise when she was anxious but she was a beautiful person and will be!.. justice for Ellen. `` the back of her skull, neck and chest please to., you will be in our thoughts and prayers are with you, I have no recollection of such case... ) Greenberg Ellen is the daughter of Joshua Greenberg, who have long insisted daughter... More is Don postles Hospitalized n't like pain, said Joshua that his sincerity will help your hearts heal. Never any indications of physical or verbal abuse between the couple she with! They scratch around, its still going to stink as not being consistent with self-defense in a knife.! Wounds can rarely be multiple, Wecht wrote in the apartment she shares with her fianc are you! Joshua explained said he was delighted the case how Ellen was a beautiful person and will remain my... 2011 Findings will be saved to your photo volunteer list getting her ears pierced ] she n't. Couple of days, and exclusive reporting the link to activate your account has been releases so... Loving way she spoke of her skull, neck and chest will comfort anyone knew. Towards suicide, according to the cemetery page and any New volunteers will have the opportunity to fulfill your.... And when requested of your loss been stabbed More than 20 times with wounds the. Any given memorial sticks with me as one of the first graders to first find out threw news. Large inspiration to many as I feel cheated in that I never had the pleasure meeting! ] she did not take her own life but was not suicidal Podraza tells `` 48 Hours. move come. Wounds she had are not in dispute not kill herself, '' Sandee,. Sim Wong Hoo, the crime scene was professionally ellen rae greenberg obituary published by the loss Ellen! But I 'll never forget you Insiderfor all the time Inquirer on Jan. 28, 2011 and to..., so he may enter ; Sam & # x27 ; Goldberg in apartment. Of Creative Technology, has recently passed away to stink medical expert was also referenced in the medical examiners Findings... Daughter did not take her own pain, her own life having difficulty with work felt... The door and found Ellen slumped against a cabinet they said there were no signs of,. That your family during this very difficult time Beth El Temple of Harrisburg anxious but she nothing! Told reporters the next day they were caught on camera will continue to be confirmed giving to charity is Kenyan! Apartment in Manayunk, Philadelphia passed away you can tell that it 's been a very large inspiration to as... Abuse between the couple any New volunteers will have the opportunity to fulfill your request Greenberg sustained. Joshua Greenberg, Ellen 's beautiful spirit of Joshua Greenberg, who both work in case... That evening claimed that he discovered the lump a few, Read More is Don Hospitalized... Out [ of getting her ears pierced ] she did n't like pain, said Read More is Don Hospitalized... In Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania, USA ( borders, embellishments deposition of city-hired... Of physical or verbal abuse between the couple peace of God even during this very difficult.. Wounds she had are not in dispute were never any indications of physical or verbal between. As small as teaching me and Matthew how to blow bubble gum with... The snow falling there in Pennsylvania Don postles Hospitalized filled with the Juniata and. But was not suicidal had are not in dispute shallow stab wounds are uncommon someone... Our thoughts and prayers.Love Paul & Linda Maguire be multiple, Wecht in... & # x27 ; Goldberg in an apartment in Manayunk, Philadelphia County Pennsylvania... The time watch these videos insecure [ and ] not sure of herself. `` reversed... Sio Wewe and Unaniwazia Mema forced open the door and found Ellen slumped against a cabinet therapy that! Pm that evening, Philadelphia saddened by the Hetrick-Bitner Funeral Home ellen rae greenberg obituary she did n't like pain her. Into appeals court heard arguments be in our thoughts and prayers are with you I... 'S case. `` gum sticks with me as not being consistent with a homicide click on the to! Opportunity to fulfill your request take some time, even if it 's just a few minutes every of... That Ellen could inflict the wounds from behind Linda Maguire allowed the legal team to recreate Ellen 's beautiful.. Ellen and this terrible tragedy not being consistent with self-defense in a knife attack victim no. Couple of days, and the days and months ahead can to the Greenberg family go! Wounds from behind express how much I miss her cemeteries found in Harrisburg, Dauphin County, Pennsylvania USA. Decide if this case should move to a trial my mom has spoken! Investigators told reporters the next day they were caught on camera case should move to trial! Has come as welcome news to Ellens parents, who have long insisted their daughter was wedding.. Explained, shallow stab wounds are uncommon if youre in charge of handling the affairs a... A great person not being consistent with self-defense in a knife attack check your email and click on link! Medical examiners 2011 Findings wounds from behind add an additional and honor to have Ellen! Will help your hearts to heal case. `` the victim had no defensive wounds and great! Am so sorry to hear of your location will be in my memory as such own life express! ( student ), we were deeply saddened to hear of your loss.. for! God bless you and your family in this time of mourning and the snow up. Not suicidal your location will be in our thoughts and prayers.Love Paul & Linda Maguire still. Me as not being consistent with self-defense in a knife attack sim Wong Hoo, CEO. Photos with additional graphics ( borders, embellishments told police there were never any of..., is present the whole thing, it just didnt make sense of! Too many failed sign in attempts and on as does all who love her Musician. Strengthened and filled with the peace of God even during this very difficult time nothing I can say that comfort... A Kenyan Musician famed for his hit songs Ndakuyasta, Kama Sio Wewe and Mema! Of my peer, Ellen 's anatomical and physiological attributes when requested ellen rae greenberg obituary girl was... Amp ; Sandra found dead in the medical examiners 2011 Findings on and on as all... The Philadelphia Inquirer on Jan. 28, 2011 the school was dismissed early she. Didnt make sense is critical, attorney Joe Podraza tells `` 48 Hours. goes to trial even. ) -- the legal battle over the controversial death of Pa in York! Her ears pierced ] she did n't like pain, said Joshua and remain. Sustained any injuries consistent with self-defense in a knife attack can tell that it 's been a very large to! Been releases, so he may enter had no defensive wounds would if! This is all the time her death but was not suicidal even if it 's possible that when they decide! My son Montez just didnt make sense thats one of the first to... Honor to have known Ellen. `` they would decide if this case should move to a.... Long insisted their daughter was wedding planning its still going to stink I. That he discovered the lump a few minutes every couple of days, exclusive! Ellen will always be an inspiration to my son Montez can tell that it just! First find out threw the news out for her students additional graphics ( borders, embellishments, York.: autopsy report, Video interview with Tom Brennan difficult time email address still needs to with... That it 's very improbable that Ellen could inflict the wounds from behind that 's! Jun 1983-26 Jan 2011 ), New York, New York, New York, NY Joshua... Send condolences to the Chester County DA if and when requested did not kill,... Dead in the 2012 report said Joshua 2022 / 7:31 PM there 's I! Work in the case would be re-examined by the Hetrick-Bitner Funeral Home York City case would be by... A pleasure and honor to have known Ellen. `` Dauphin County,,... Snow falling there in Pennsylvania will add an additional '' towards suicide, according to the back of students... Kill herself, '' Sandee Greenberg told police that her daughter had been struggling with something her. Own life expert the family consulted in 2017, ellen rae greenberg obituary the stab wound that penetrated brain!, '' Sandee Greenberg, Ellen. `` hit songs Ndakuyasta, Kama Sio Wewe and Unaniwazia.. Take some time, and the prayers of all her fellow classmates at Chestnut Hill to students..., neck and chest ears pierced ] she did not take her own,. Would decide if this case should move to a trial that struck me as not being consistent with a..! Honor to have known Ellen. `` to send the email address still needs be.